Article

< Back to Blog

Cedar Roofs vs. Slate: Which Is the Best Choice?

Choosing the right roofing material for your home affects the appearance of your property, its longevity, value, and environmental impact. Two of the most popular choices for high-end roofing are cedar roofs and slate and tile roofing, each with its own advantages. 

Is a Cedar Roof Better Than a Slate Roof?

Cedar roofs offer a rustic look, natural insulation, and energy efficiency but require regular maintenance. Slate roofs are highly durable, fire-resistant, and low-maintenance, lasting over a century, though they are more expensive and need strong structural support. The choice depends on budget, maintenance preference, home style, and climate.

Appearance and Aesthetics

Cedar shingles and shakes provide a warm, natural appeal that blends seamlessly with rustic, traditional, or historic-style homes. The rich, earthy tones of cedar mature over time, aging into an elegant silvery-gray patina that adds character and charm.

On the other hand, slate roofs exude sophistication and prestige. With their sleek, stone-like appearance, slate tiles are often associated with classic architecture, adding a refined and elegant touch to any property. 

Longevity and Durability

Cedar is naturally resistant to insects and moisture, especially when properly treated and maintained. A high-quality cedar roof can last between 30 and 50 years, though it requires periodic maintenance, such as sealing and moss removal, to maintain its resilience.

Slate, however, is one of the most durable roofing materials available, with a lifespan ranging from 75 to over 100 years. As a natural stone, slate is highly resistant to fire, extreme weather conditions, and rot. While slate tiles are incredibly strong, they can be fragile under impact, making careful installation and occasional maintenance essential.

Home Value and Availability

Cedar's natural beauty and insulation properties are appealing features, especially in areas where wood roofing is popular. However, cedar shingles are not as widely available as asphalt shingles, and their cost can be higher due to the craftsmanship required for installation.

Slate, being a premium roofing material, instantly elevates a home’s marketability. While the initial investment is substantial, the long-term benefits outweigh the cost, particularly for homeowners looking for longevity and minimal maintenance. 

Environmental Benefits

When it comes to sustainability, both cedar and slate are eco-friendly roofing options. Cedar is a renewable resource with a low carbon footprint when sourced responsibly. It also provides natural insulation, reducing energy costs. Slate is highly sustainable due to its longevity—lasting over a century, minimizing waste, and requiring no chemical treatments.

Contact Heather & Little for Slate and Tile Roofing or Cedar Roofs for Your Building

Your home deserves a roof that’s as strong and beautiful as it is lasting. Whether you're captivated by the rustic warmth of cedar roofs or drawn to the timeless elegance of slate and rile roofing, your choice should reflect your vision, budget, and long-term goals. Contact us to explore the best roofing solutions for your property and get a quote.

Preservation Consulting

And if you are looking for a second opinion on your project or have a particularly complex issue that needs a fresh eye, we’re here for that too. Tackling tricky challenges is our specialty and we welcome the opportunity to provide consulting advice, with the same exacting attention to detail we bring to all our commissions.

© 2025 Heather & Little Limited